For much of the past three years, cash has looked like a sensible choice. Yields near 4% and no visible volatility on account statements — what is not to like? In a new Weekly View1, RiverFront Investment Group's Dan Zolet, CFA, challenges the entire framework investors are using to evaluate that choice.
Reframe the Question
The issue, Zolet argues, is not what investors are asking but what they are not. "Instead of 'Will my balance go down?' ask 'Will my money do its job?'" That job is to help investors reach long-term financial goals: funding retirement, paying for a child's education, leaving a legacy. Judged by that standard, the apparent safety of cash dissolves quickly.
"Cash has no 'statement risk': its value doesn't swing from one account statement to the next," Zolet observes. But beneath that calm surface sit three risks that do not show up on monthly statements: reinvestment risk, inflation, and opportunity cost. By changing the frame of reference, Zolet notes, "zero volatility risk does not feel as safe."
The Rented Yield Problem
The first hidden risk goes to the heart of why cash feels attractive right now. Today's yields of around 4% look compelling after a decade near zero, but they are not locked in. "Money market funds and T-bills reset continuously, so if the Fed cuts rates, cash investors feel it almost immediately," Zolet notes. "In short, the yield on cash is 'rented', not owned."
This matters profoundly for planning. A rented yield cannot anchor a financial forecast. It "can, potentially, be trusted to help match liabilities in the short term, but any cash need further than a year in the future becomes more uncertain." Longer-duration instruments offer a different proposition. Zolet points to the US ten-year Treasury, currently yielding approximately 5.12%: "If held to maturity, that bond will pay its fixed coupon each year for its 10-year holding period." The cash flow is predictable. The tradeoff is price volatility if sold before maturity, but that is a manageable risk for investors with appropriate horizons.
Inflation and Opportunity: The Invisible Drain
The case against cash deepens when inflation enters the picture. "Cash yields rarely stay meaningfully above the annual rate of inflation for extended periods of time," Zolet observes. The cumulative damage is concrete: over the last 15 years, money held in cash lost 14% of its purchasing power in real terms, a loss with no statement to show it.
Equities, Zolet argues, "have historically been able to generate returns that outpace inflation over longer periods, in part because companies can often raise prices, grow earnings, and reinvest in their businesses as costs rise." That outperformance carries greater short-term volatility, but for investors with distant liabilities, sitting out the compounding machine carries its own cost.
Opportunity cost runs alongside inflation risk. Zolet flags an underappreciated dimension in longevity: "If an investor's time horizon shifts mid investment (mainly due to increased longevity), the lack of capital appreciation can become an unforeseen issue." A 60-year-old who lives to 90 did not plan to hold cash for 30 years.
Getting Cash Back to Work
Identifying the risks is the easier task. Execution is harder. Zolet proposes a two-pronged reinvestment strategy. The first prong involves setting entry levels based on current market conditions and fundamentals. The second removes timing from the equation entirely: "setting up a time-based dollar cost averaging schedule, along with a firm date by which 100% of the funds are invested" ensures an investor "is not sitting out of a market waiting for the perfect pitch but instead is steadily investing into the market." Together, the two approaches serve both the analytical investor who needs conviction levels and the behaviorally driven investor who needs structure.
The transition is not emotionally neutral. Even conservative instruments like US Treasuries introduce volatility. "Taking risk involves the emotion of watching the value of your portfolio change," Zolet acknowledges. This is precisely where professional guidance becomes decisive. An experienced advisor can draw on tools and strategies tailored to each client's risk tolerance, time horizon, and liquidity needs. RiverFront's model and custom portfolio solutions are designed to support advisors navigating exactly this kind of migration.
5 Key Takeaways for Advisors and Investors
- Reframe the risk question. "Will my balance go down?" is the wrong benchmark for long-term investors. The operative question is whether money is positioned to reach financial goals.
- Cash yields are rented, not owned. Rate resets happen immediately when monetary policy shifts. Locking in yield requires duration.
- Inflation quietly erodes cash. Over 15 years, cash holders lost 14% of purchasing power in real terms: a significant loss with nothing on the statement to show for it.
- Longevity extends the horizon. Investors who outlive their own projections need capital appreciation, not cash stability.
- A two-pronged reinvestment plan bridges psychology and discipline. Combining fundamental entry levels with a time-based dollar cost averaging schedule removes the paralysis of waiting for the perfect moment.
Footnote:
1 Zolet, Dan. "Will My Money Do Its Job?" RiverFront Investment Group Weekly View, 17 Nov. 2026, https://www.riverfrontig.com/insights/will-my-money-do-its-job/.