In a November 11, 2026 addendum to his monthly equity market commentary1, Andrew Slimmon, Managing Director at Morgan Stanley Investment Management, opens with a candid admission: for most of 2026 he had warned that midterm years bring elevated volatility and deeper drawdowns, and for most of 2026 he felt "like a dope." The market was calm. Then October arrived.
His central argument cuts through the political noise with a single declarative: "When equity markets are consumed with what is occurring in Washington DC, it's almost always a good buying opportunity." The historical support is unbroken. Since the S&P 500 started in 1950, the stock market has been higher 6 and 12 months later 19 out of 19 midterm elections. The 2006 analog is instructive. An unpopular Republican president, an unpopular war in the Middle East, and a Democratic sweep of the House and Senate preceded an S&P 500 gain of approximately 5% three months later and 9% six months out. Slimmon's point is unambiguous: "I don't think 2026 will be an aberration. Every mid-term election feels like an aberration, and yet not one has been."
Not a Broad Buy Signal
That historical confidence does not translate into a blanket buy. With the S&P 500 down only about 6% as of the November 5 close, Slimmon does not consider it a meaningful correction. "I don't think the market overall is offering an unusual buying opportunity," he says, noting that 12-month returns become statistically more attractive only when the index is down close to 15% from its highs. He wants to see the S&P 500 below the 7,000 level before becoming more interested than normal. What has contained the downside is a valuation derating: "A forward P/E of 17.8x (lower valuation) combined with the continuous upward revision in earnings (better fundamentals) has limited the downside risk, in my opinion."
Carnage Beneath the Hood
The index tells a different story than the internals. As of November 5, the iShares SOXX was down approximately 40% from its June high, the DRAM ETF approximately 55%, and an AI beneficiaries basket approximately 46%. "Looking under the S&P 500 hood, there is a lot of carnage," Slimmon says. "That is where the opportunities lie, in my opinion."
On AI infrastructure, he resists the market's implied verdict: "The magnitude of the Ai infrastructure selloff suggests the market is pricing in not a slowdown, but a buildout cessation. I question that." He cites newly elected Texas Governor Gina Hinojosa, who said in a post-election CNN interview: "It is not that I hate data centers. I hate the way they are taking advantage of Texas, and that stops when I'm governor... We can have a strong economy, strong industry, and protections for the people of Texas. Those things are not mutually exclusive." Slimmon's read: "I interpret Hinojosa's comments as saying, 'we need them to fund more into the communities.'" His conclusion is a slowdown, not a cessation, with Meta and Oracle already demonstrating the community-investment model in Louisiana and New Mexico.
The Defensive Trade Does Not Hold Up
Capital rotated into consumer staples and healthcare, not out of the market, which partly explains why the index-level decline was contained. October was the best month for consumer staples in 20 years, and healthcare outperformed the NASDAQ by 16 percentage points. Both were three-standard-deviation events. Yet the fundamental case for either sector is absent. "Earnings revisions breadth across healthcare and consumer staples have deteriorated, suggesting there has been no material improvement in the fundamentals." When Slimmon asks whether conditions truly warrant the rotation, his answer is unsparing: "Is it really this bad for technology? Has it really gotten this much better for staples/healthcare? I say, 'no' and 'no!'"
He acknowledges a blind spot: "We clearly underestimated the crowding of the fast money into Ai stocks and shorting of the perceived defensives. The big Democratic victory simply ignited the eruption under those positions." The resulting hedge fund deleveraging has been disorienting. While retail investors remain calm and long-term oriented, Slimmon is pointed about the institutional actors driving intraday volatility: levered hedge funds have acted as "chickens with their heads chopped off (IMO), moving daily stock prices around at nonsensical speeds." His interpretation of the resulting divergences: "I favor the former!"
Inflation Is the Variable That Matters
Political outcomes are secondary to monetary policy in Slimmon's framework: "I remain in the camp that the direction and trajectory of Fed rate policy is a far bigger issue for equities. It's all about inflation." Lower oil prices could help inflation trend toward the Fed's 2% target, allowing the compressed multiple to rerate higher. The risk scenario is 2027: "2027 will be a more challenging year for equites if inflation does not improve and the Fed is forced to raise rates more than Wall Street anticipates."
His closing line anchors the entire analysis: "I think the market has overreacted to the midterms intra-sectorally, offering intriguing opportunities."
Five Key Takeaways for Advisors and Investors
- The midterm signal is perfect. The S&P 500 has been higher six and twelve months after every one of the 19 midterm elections since 1950. Slimmon sees no structural reason 2026 breaks that record.
- A 6% pullback is not a buying opportunity at the index level. Slimmon's threshold for increased conviction is the S&P 500 below 7,000, requiring a drawdown closer to 15% from highs.
- The real dislocations are beneath the surface. Semiconductors, DRAM, and AI beneficiary stocks are down 40% to 55% from their June highs, pricing in a buildout cessation that Slimmon does not believe is coming.
- The defensive rotation into staples and healthcare is technically driven, not fundamentally justified. Earnings revisions in both sectors have deteriorated, making the outperformance fragile when sentiment normalizes.
- The dominant variable for equities in 2027 is inflation and Fed rate trajectory, not midterm outcomes. A path toward 2% inflation opens the door to multiple expansion. Persistent inflation and additional rate hikes close it.
Footnote:
1 Slimmon, Andrew. "Equity Market Commentary - November 2026 Addendum." Morgan Stanley Investment Management, 11 Nov. 2026, www.morganstanley.com/im/en-be/intermediary-investor/insights/slimmons-take/equity-market-commentary-nov-2026-addendum.html.