Is China Investable Again?

October 8, 2024

7 minute read

by Jeffrey Kleintop, Chief Global Market Strategist, Charles Schwab & Company

Should China deliver sufficient stimulus to break the cycle of tightening fiscal policy, we may find China, and emerging markets, investable again.

What would it take for the recent rally in China's stock market to become sustainable and one of the biggest bull markets for China of the past 20 years? A lot—but it's not impossible.

A new bull market

During the past few years, we've written about the need for China to deliver much more powerful stimulus and been repeatedly disappointed. China's stock market was near the low end of its 15-year range as of mid-September, trading at a forward price-to-earnings ratio of less than 9, near its lowest levels of the past 20 years. As the biggest weight in the MSCI Emerging Market Index, China had been dragging down the performance of the emerging market (EM) stocks asset class. From the end of 2020 until the day before China's announcement of new stimulus on September 25, 2024, the total return of the MSCI Emerging Market Index was a loss of -3%, while the MSCI Emerging Market Ex-China Index produced a 21% gain.

China acted as a drag on EM stocks from the end of 2020 until late September

Line chart shows performance of the MSCI Emerging Markets Index and the MSCI Emerging Markets ex China Index from the end of 2020 through September 24, 2024.

Total return in US dollars for both indexes.

Source: Charles Schwab, Bloomberg data from 12/31/220 through 9/24/2024 retrieved on 10/4/2024. Indexes are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, costs and expenses, and cannot be invested in directly. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

September's announcement brought a surprise and emerging market stocks, as measured by the MSCI Emerging Market Index, ended the third quarter having outperformed the S&P 500 Index. The press release of a major Chinese stimulus program lifted China's stocks into a new bull market from their mid-September low, just ahead of the weeklong market closure for the Golden Week holiday that started October 1.

Just to review, China's stocks have experienced four stimulus-driven bull markets over the past four years—including the one earlier this year in May—and the prior three all soon fizzled out, reversing their gains.

Past bull markets have fizzled out

Line chart of the MSCI China total return index from February 2021 through October 2024, with the four bull market rallies highlighted.

Source: Charles Schwab, Bloomberg data as of 10/4/2024.

Indexes are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, costs and expenses, and cannot be invested in directly. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

What is China's problem?

China's economic problems feed into each other—so let's walk around this circle. China's weak property market caused fiscal policy to aggressively tighten this year which reinforced the drag on the economy and further weakened the property market. Trying to break the cycle, China's central bank announced aggressive monetary policy easing on September 24; including cutting the one-year prime loan rate to its lowest level since the People's Bank of China began using it as the main policy rate in 2016.

Real estate recession: China real estate investment as a percent of GDP

Line chart of Chinese real estate investment from 1992 through 2024.

Source: Charles Schwab, OECD, Macrobond data as of 10/4/2024.

Fiscal spending has come in a lot lower than last year and policymakers' plans in the budget that was submitted to the National People Congress in early March. In China, the general government budget only tells part of the fiscal story. China has three additional national budgets: the government funds budget, the state capital operations budget, and the social insurance fund budget. The government funds budget is the source of the fiscal tightening.

The 2024 plan was for China's government funds budget to include 7 trillion renminbi in revenue and 12 trillion of spending, resulting in a deficit of 5 trillion. The planned deficit was expanded from 4 trillion last year, to provide an economic boost. As of the end of August, two-thirds the way through the year, the deficit was only 2.1 trillion. Planned fiscal policy would have allowed for the deficit level to be around 3.7 trillion at this point. As a result, there was an unintended 1.6 trillion tightening of fiscal policy, acting as a drag on the economy.

Unintended tightening of fiscal policy

Line chart shows China's 2023 deficit, the projected 2024 deficit, and the current 2024 deficit through August as each progressed from January through December.

Source: Charles Schwab, China Ministry of Finance, Macrobond data as of 10/4/2024.

The shrinking government funds budget comes from local governments' sales of land again coming in much weaker than anticipated following China's clampdown on borrowing by large real estate developers. The slow pace of land sales means revenue is down 21% from last year and local government spending on land infrastructure upgrades for development has been impacted. Therefore, the weak property market gave rise to lower government spending, which has acted as a drag on the economy and subsequently reinforced the weakness in the property market.

To make up for the shortfall and try to break this cycle of weakness, local governments could possibly issue special local government bonds to finance more infrastructure spending. However, the current quota for special-purpose local bonds was set in March and has not yet been boosted to account for the accumulating shortfall. Furthermore, the central government seems to be slow to approve projects for special bond funding, possibly wanting to avoid losses as property values continue to fall. Consequently, local government bond issuance at this point in the year has come in below the now insufficient quota.

Special bond issuance may accelerate in the fourth quarter. Should it move toward closing the gap and fulfilling the quota, it could turn around the government fund deficit from a fiscal drag of about 2 trillion to closer to 1 trillion. It might help, but at that level, spending would still be far from the planned 1 trillion fiscal expansion. The government funds deficit was also around 1 trillion smaller than budgeted in both 2022 and 2023, which contributed to China's lingering economic malaise.

China's aggressive easing of monetary policy by its central bank is unlikely to stimulate economic activity absent a break in the cycle of tightening fiscal policy. As a result, China's stock market rally could fizzle and give back much of the gains as it did in May when prior stimulus announcements ultimately failed to deliver real support to the economy.

What we are watching to see if it works

China's policymakers have announced interest rate cuts and plans to issue more central government bonds to try to address both monetary and fiscal stimulus, according to official government statements. It's a move in the right direction, but there are a few things we're looking for to judge whether the stimulus announcements deliver the boost to China's growth that may sustain its stock market's gains.

Boosting local government special bond issuance. Raising the special bond issuance quota by more than 1 trillion renminbi would be needed to ease tight fiscal policy. Last year, the central government decided in October to issue an additional 1 trillion in bonds for the year. We feel more would be needed this year to boost growth, given the deeper property downturn. Following monetary policy easing announcements from the People's Bank of China (PBOC) earlier in the week, China's Politburo announced 2 trillion in issuance of special treasury bonds by the central government on September 26th. An announcement on fiscal support for 2024 could come the week of October 22, in conjunction with the Standing Committee meeting.
Faster money supply growth in China. To see if expansionary monetary policy is working to offset the fiscal tightening, we can track the pace of money supply growth. The stimulus by the People's Bank of China is intended to turn around very weak borrowing by businesses and consumers to fuel growth. A sign that this was working would be more demand for money. So far, money supply growth has turned negative in recent months, falling below -5% as of August.

Shrinking money supply

Line Chart of China's M1 money supply from 2019 through August 2024, the most recent data available.

Source: Charles Schwab, People's Bank of China, Bloomberg data as of 10/4/2024.

M1 money supply is the total amount of money in circulation in an economy, which can include physical currency, demand deposits and other liquid assets that may be quickly converted to cash.

A rise in consumer and business confidence. China's policymakers could guarantee homebuyer deposits and boost social safety nets to reduce high levels of precautionary savings that are keeping consumption in check and could signal they are going to reduce business interference with sudden regulatory changes that have impeded business investment. Although the stock market rally and reduction of mortgage payments could boost confidence in the near-term, consumers need hope of improvement in income and job growth for the rally to have staying power.

Very weak consumer confidence in China

Line chart shows the China Consumer Confidence Index level from 1992 through October 2024.

Source: Charles Schwab, China National Bureau of Statistics, Macrobond data as of 10/4/2024.

Is China investable?

China has been a drag on emerging-market stock performance for years. Sustainably turning that around is a formidable challenge for policymakers. Back in September 2020, the government's "three red lines" policy created restrictions on the property market to crack down on the buildup of leverage and curb speculation in housing that had driven up prices and to divert investment to more productive, high-tech areas of the economy. The policy worked too well and ended up starving developers of capital, causing a loss of confidence by homebuyers and price decline that became a self-reinforcing negative feedback loop. Abrupt changes in regulations on businesses and scarring from zero-COVID policies that reduced income growth and job prospects kept pressure on consumer and business confidence. On the property front, mortgage and down-payment rates have been lowered, and homebuying restrictions in some cities have been relaxed. However, the lack of funding for property developers has not been addressed. It will take a lot for the stimulus announcements to sustainably change China's economic and stock market trajectory—but it's not impossible.

China's policymakers have already announced interest rate cuts and plans to issue more central government bonds to try to address both monetary and fiscal stimulus. Consumer confidence could begin to turn around and create a positive feedback loop for the economy. While China's policymakers are at last signaling that they understand the need for major stimulus, without sufficient follow-through on these announcements, the stock market rally may not continue and instead is likely to follow the path of prior announcements and give back nearly all the gains over the coming months. But if the policymakers deliver, the tradable rally in emerging-market stocks could turn into a sustainable bull market and, in the minds of many investors, make China (and emerging markets) investible again.

Michelle Gibley, CFA^®, Director of International Research, and Heather O'Leary, Senior Global Investment Research Analyst, contributed to this report.

Starlight's Dennis Mitchell: Outlook 2024 – Diverse Bets for Uncertainty