Archive for October, 2010
So Now What?
Sunday, October 31st, 2010
Schwab Market Perspective: So Now What?
Charles Schwab & Co. Inc.
Liz Ann Sonders
Senior Vice President, Chief Investment Strategist, Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.,
Brad Sorensen
CFA, Director of Market and Sector Analysis, Schwab Center for Financial Research, and
Michelle Gibley
CFA, Senior Market Analyst, Schwab Center for Financial Research
October 29, 2010
Key points
- The Federal Reserve and upcoming elections are in sharp focus and results and actions could to determine whether the momentum seen since September can continue.
- Earnings season was better than expected and the market reacted as such. But confidence remains a major issue, with brewing mortgage-related problems and continued uncertainty around tax policy causing consternation.
- Debt remains a major issue that's just now being addressed and protectionism still threatens economic expansion. China remains a bright spot for global growth.
Markets have been so focused on the potential for more Fed action and the outcome of the November 2 elections that the question becomes: What now? We believe we may start to see a shift in sentiment. During the past couple of months, stocks have rallied on somewhat weak economic data that was perceived as increasing the odds of another round of quantitative easing (the Fed injecting cash into the economy through the purchase of assets). Lately, the economic news has been at least marginally more positive.
Going forward, investors likely want to see fruit from any further Fed action and see more consistent improvement in economic data, especially jobs and housing. Similarly, markets were boosted heading into the elections on hopes that a new mix in Congress would lead to some tax and regulatory certainty—now it will be important to see that optimism fulfilled.
It will take some time to see the effects of these long-awaited events, and we believe some near-term consolidation in the stock markets is likely. We saw a hint of that following the very modest interest-rate increase out of China, but that was quickly reversed. As repeatedly noted, the market is a forward-looking mechanism, and we wouldn't be surprised to see some "buy the rumor, sell the news" action.
Investor sentiment has gotten a little stretched on the optimistic side (a contrarian indicator) and some technical indicators have reached levels that indicate stocks are somewhat overbought.
We again remind you to use this potential volatility to adjust your asset allocations as needed. Stocks should be viewed as a long-term investment (three to five years or longer) and short-term gyrations should be viewed as opportunities to align your investments with that in mind.
Economy back in focus
After a brief respite to focus on third-quarter earnings reports, full attention likely now turns back to the broader economy. After a couple of months of cheering tepid data due to its perceived influence on the Fed, more traction is likely needed to continue recent momentum.
The first read on third quarter GDP was in-line with expectations at 2%, up from 1.7% in the second quarter. Industrial production surprisingly declined 0.2% in September, while capacity utilization remained unchanged at 74.7%—5.9% below its 1972–2009 average, indicating continued cautiousness in the corporate sector. Companies have vast amounts of cash on their balance sheets. Unfortunately, for now, that money is largely just sitting on balance sheets.
Money Needs to Move

Click to enlarge
Source: FactSet, the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, and the Federal Reserve, as of October 25, 2010.
*M2 velocity = GDP divided by M2 money supply.
We believe that cash will be soon put to work. With more certainty likely following early November's Fed meeting and elections, companies seem likely to look to deploy more of that capital.
Tags: Brazil, BRIC, BRICs, Canadian Market, Charles Schwab, Chief Investment Strategist, China, Consistent Improvement, Consternation, Earnings Season, Economic Data, Economic Expansion, Economic News, Global Growth Markets, India, Liz Ann, Market Analyst, Market Perspective, November 2, Protectionism, Rate Increase, Russia, Sector Analysis, Senior Vice President, Stock Markets, Upcoming Elections, Will Take Some Time
Posted in Brazil, Canadian Market, China, India, Markets, Outlook | Comments Off
Retirement Disaster Ahead?
Sunday, October 31st, 2010
Brett Arends of the WSJ reports, Warning: Retirement Disaster Ahead:
Don't let the rally in the stock and bond markets fool you. Many Americans are still hurtling towards a retirement disaster. Few realize it. Even many of those running the big pension funds don't know.
That's the conclusion of John West and Rob Arnott at Research Affiliates, an investment management firm, in Newport Beach, Calif. In their latest report, "Hope Is Not A Strategy," they have some numbers to back it up.
"I worry a lot about people reaching their golden years and discovering, 'Oh, I should've saved more,' and 'Oh, I don't qualify for Social Security any more because it's means tested'," says Mr. Arnott, a widely respected market strategist. "We're headed for a retirement train wreck," he adds, "and it's going to get really ugly over the next 15 years."
Alarmist? Perhaps. But follow the math.
The returns you will get from your stock funds can only come from four things, they note: Dividends, earnings growth, inflation and changes in valuation.
Right now the dividend yield on U.S. stocks is about 2.2%, they note. Historically, earnings have only grown by a surprisingly low 1% a year in real, inflation-adjusted terms. Mr. Arnott tells me the average since 1900 is only about 1.2%, and in the last half century just 0.6%. Will we get more in the future? With the U.S. population ageing and heavily in debt? It's hard to imagine.
Throw in a 2% inflation forecast–more on this later–and Research Affiliates forecasts a long-term return of 5.2%.
What about changes in valuation? Some generations are lucky. They invest in the stock market when it's depressed and shares are cheap in relation to earnings. This was the case in the 1930s and the 1970s. Then they retire and cash out when the market is booming and shares are expensive in relation to earnings–such as in the 1960s and 1990s.
People today are not so lucky. The stock market's latest rally has lifted shares already to pretty high levels in relation to average cyclically-adjusted earnings. This so-called "Shiller PE" (named after Yale professor Robert Shiller, who popularized the notion) has been an excellent indicator of market value. Right now it's at about 22–well above its historic average of 16. The only time the market has boomed from these levels, was in the late 1990s bubble–an atypical moment unlikely to be repeated any time soon.
Now look at bonds. Thanks to the recent boom, the picture for investors here looks even worse. And there is less room for ambiguity, because bond coupons and the repayment of principal are fixed.
Based on the yields of prices across all investment grade bonds, Mr. West and Mr. Arnott calculate likely long-term bond returns from here of about 2.5%.
So an investor with 60% of his portfolio in stocks and 40% in bonds, a standard, if conservative, allocation, can expect a weighted average return from here of only about 4.1%.
To put this in context, they notice that the typical big pension fund is still expecting to earn about 7% to 8% a year.
When you strip out 2% inflation, that means pension fund managers are expecting 5–6% percent a year in real, inflation-adjusted terms.
But by Mr. West and Mr. Arnott's numbers, investors can only expect about 2.1%.
Gulp.
Here's what this means for you.
Someone who saves $10,000 a year for 30 years and invests the money at 5.5% a year will end up with $760,000.
Someone who only manages to earn 2.5% on their investments: Just $420,000.
If you're running a pension fund, this kind of shortfall leads to a funding gap that must be made up by the plan sponsor. For a private investor trying to build their own savings, it leads to a dismal retirement.
Is there any hope?
I asked Mr. Arnott about two possible sources of higher returns.
The first: Stock buybacks. Will they help? Many companies are trying to return more money to investors, on top of dividends, by buying back stock. In theory, at least, this ought to boost returns, because it reduces the number of shares, and therefore increases the value of those that remain. But Mr. Arnott cautions against relying on it. We don't know how big these buybacks will be, and we don't know if they're sustainable, he says. Furthermore, the gains are usually offset by the issue of new stock and options to management. "Most buybacks are done to facilitate the exercise of management stock options," he says.
The second possible source of better returns: Emerging markets.
Investors have been throwing money into emerging market funds recently like a hail mary pass–a last, desperate bid to snatch a decent retirement from the jaws of defeat.
But they may be substituting hope for reason. By Mr. Arnott's math, even the most heroic calculations cannot plausibly predict that earnings growth in emerging markets will be more than a couple of percentage points faster than in developed countries. And there are plenty of people who argue it won't be markedly higher, over time, at all. Why? Where economies grow more quickly, new capital flows in. Current investors find their returns diluted by new enterprises and new stockholders.
Meanwhile, look at the valuations. Stock markets in emerging economies have skyrocketed in the past two years. Hot markets like Brazil and India have nearly recovered their 2007 manic peaks. As a result, your dividend income is even worse than in the U.S. The yield on the Indian stock market is down to about 1%, according to FactSet. Brazil has dipped below 2% and China, 1.6%.
Bottom line? Neither pension funds nor private investors seem to have fully absorbed the grim lessons of the past decade. Returns are going to be much lower. People need to save more, much more, for their retirement. If the market rally this year has given them false hope, it will have turned out to be a curse more than a blessing.
I went over West and Arnott's latest report, "Hope Is Not A Strategy," and found it quite interesting. I urge you to read this report carefully, and pay particular to attention to this:
Many investors, keenly aware that returns will be lower than the past 30 years, have turned to alternative categories like hedge funds, private equity, infrastructure, emerging markets, timberland, and so forth, in a quest for equity-like returns and diversification of risk. This eclectic group has a relatively short history, dubious data (i.e. survivorship bias), and a heavy reliance on the most difficult metric of all to forecast—manager alpha. Thus, Polly simply took the 75th percentile 10-year return for the HFRI Hedge Fund of Fund Composite, which equated to 9.4%.9 Even with the boost from survivorship bias, this gets us no better than the top-quartile stock market return. Still, her 8% return assumption does seem within reach.
...
Table 3 illustrates that Polly can “get there” only by assuming top quartile results for stocks, bonds, and alternatives. Furthermore, all three must produce these lofty results simultaneously over the same span! What are the odds of that? Assuming these projections are representative, this works out to 25% × 25% × 25%, or about a 1.6% chance. Yikes!
This is exactly what the overwhelming majority of the U.S. retirement market—pension funds, state budgets, IRAs, 401(k)s, etc.—is not only hoping for but depending upon. That’s $16 trillion of assets expecting a decade of sunshine to achieve the 7–8% targeted returns used for planning and budgeting purposes.
This report highlights the problem pension funds and individuals face when they "hope" their rosy investment forecasts come true. They're setting themselves up for a fall. The only way they can achieve these results is by taking on more risk, but this can backfire if disaster strikes like it did in 2008. Hope isn't a strategy, and even though the Fed keeps pumping tons of liquidity into the financial system, it won't make a difference in averting the major retirement disaster that lies ahead.
Tags: 1930s, 1960s, 1990s, Bond Markets, Brazil, China, Dividend Yield, Dividends, Earnings Growth, Hope Is Not A Strategy, India, inflation, Investment Management Firm, Market Strategist, Newport Beach, Pension Funds, Population Ageing, Research Affiliates, Rob Arnott, Stock Funds, Stock Market, Train Wreck, Wsj
Posted in Brazil, China, Gold, India, Infrastructure, Markets | Comments Off
Marc Faber: Fed's QE2 Could Trigger Market Correction
Sunday, October 31st, 2010
Marc Faber, publisher of the Gloom, Boom & Doom report, discusses the potential impact of further quantitative easing (QE2) by the U.S. Federal Reserve in a Bloomberg interview on Oct. 36 (clip below).
Correction Triggered by QE2?
Faber sees Democrats–"sadly enough"–would get a shot at still retaining the majority, which would mean the monetary and fiscal policy will most likely stay on its current course.
Equity has done well in Sep. and Oct months; however, Faber thinks the markets are stretched in the inflation trade, and weak dollar, high commodity and precious metal prices, along with high equity valuations, all suggest a correction is overdue.
Now, with QE2 being largely priced in, anything less than $1 trillion from the Fed would disappoint the markets and may trigger a correction in U.S. stocks, which could result in more quantitative easing.
But the correction should provide a buying opportunity for investors leading to an up cycle, instead of another bear market.
Equity Better for the Next Decade
Looking at investing for the next ten years, equities, emerging economies in particular, would be a relatively better place to invest than U.S. government bonds, and cash. However, Faber advises against financial, auto, and aircraft. He's been in the high tech sector and likes Microsoft (MSFT).
Precious Metals Due for Pullback
Faber is currently recommending agriculture commodities, and the accumulation of precious metals. On precious metals, he thinks they are overdue for "some kind of correction" by year end, and expect the next leg up in 2011.
Dollar Near An Inflection Point
Faber says dollar is oversold, while in contrast, some of the foreign currencies such as Yen and Franc are overbought. So, an inflection point could be near for a short-term dollar rally which could temporarily push down asset prices.
He warns investors to be very careful about shorting dollar and long assets as the trade has become quite crowded.
Expect a Strong Pullback of Chinese Economy
Although not quite gloom and doom, Faber does expect a "strong pullback" on the Chinese economy due to its many imbalances.
According to Faber, the 0.25% interest rate hike effective Oct. 20 by the PBoC is "meaningless," because of skyrocketing property prices, and the cost of living inflation has gone up much more than the official figure.
He notes food prices have seen high inflation, and because of low GDP per capita where food would account for a high percentage of total expenditure, Faber estimates that the typical consumer inflation rate in countries like China, India, and Vietnam should be around 8 to 18 percent per year.
My Take on China Inflation
The inflation rate in China was last reported at 3.60 percent in September of 2010, climbing at the fastest pace in two years. However, there are some hidden rampant inflation such as 50% on apparel, 20% on food, as reported by BusinessWeek.
Many analysts as well as academics also question how China could have such relatively moderate inflation rate given its double-digit growth and upward pressure on wages.
There's also another indicator–growth of money supply–which historically has strong correlation with inflation. China's money supply, M1 and M2, has expanded by 56 percent and 53 percent respectively over the past two years. Currently, with the various tightening measures, both measures are still growing at an annual growth rate of about 20 percent.
Furthermore, the continuing massive rural-to-urban migration will likely keep pushing up rents and food prices, and wages are expected to rise around 8 percent this year.
As consumer inflation is typically a lagging indicator, China may experience continuing higher CPI. That means Beijing is facing an increasingly difficult task of containing inflation, while maintaining sufficient growth to prevent a mass civil unrest. As such, there will likely be more tightening measures, which would put the markets on a few roller coaster rides in the next two years or so.
Nevertheless, since Chinese policymakers seem keenly aware of the risk involved and are already taking actions (which is the key), I believe China is heading towards more sustainable growth. However, if China's "on a treadmill to hell" as Jim Chanos says, you can bet that the United States will be dragged along for the ride as well.
Video Source: Bloomberg via YouTube
Tags: Accumulation, Agriculture Commodities, Asset Prices, Bear Market, China, Commodities, Emerging Economies, Federal Reserve, Foreign Currencies, Franc, Gloom, India, Inflection Point, Marc Faber, Market Equity, Monetary And Fiscal Policy, Msft, Precious Metal Prices, precious metals, Pullback, Qe2, U S Government Bonds, Valuations
Posted in China, India, Markets | Comments Off
Niall Ferguson: Chinese more Committed to Capitalism than U.S.
Sunday, October 31st, 2010
In a panel about getting America back from the depths of economic despair at The Daily Beast’s Innovators Summit – Reboot America in New Orleans, Niall Ferguson, historian and Harvard Business School professor, told Sir Harold Evans that “the Chinese are more committed to capitalism than we are”.
Source: The Daily Beast (via YouTube), October 22, 2010.
Tags: Beast, capitalism, Economic Despair, Harold Evans, Harvard Business School, Historian, Innovators, New Orleans, Niall Ferguson, Reboot, School Professor, Sir Harold, Summit, Youtube
Posted in Markets | Comments Off
Good Looking Junk?
Saturday, October 30th, 2010
While the S&P 500 has yet to take out its bull market highs, the high yield junk bond market has been making new highs for weeks now. A six-month chart of the high yield bond ETF (HYG) is shown in the first chart below. HYG has now been in a nice uptrend for the past five months, and within the last few weeks it made a new bull market high. The less risky investment grade ETF (LQD) has struggled recently and can't seem to break away from its 50-day moving average. Since the March 9th, 2009 financial crisis low, the junk bond market (HYG) is up 47%, while investment grade corporates (LQD) are up 24.1%, and this doesn't even include dividends (interest payements). With junk breaking out to new highs recently, the equity market shouldn't be far behind, right?



Copyright © Bespoke Investment Group
U.S. Equity Market Diary (November 1, 2010)
Saturday, October 30th, 2010
U.S. Equity Market Diary (November 1, 2010)
The figure below shows the performance of each sector in the S&P 500 Index for the week. Four sectors gained and six declined. The best-performing sector was materials, up 1.39 percent. Other better-performing sectors included technology and consumer discretionary. The three worst-performing sectors were industrials, utilities, and financials.
Within the materials sector, the best-performing stock was Allegheny Technologies Inc, up 13 percent. Other top-five performers were International Paper Co., Ball Corp., Titanium Metals Corp., and FMC Corp.

Strengths
- The photographic products group was the best-performing group for the week, up 20 percent, led by the group’s single member, Eastman Kodak Co. The firm reported a smaller loss in the third quarter than the analyst consensus loss estimate. The results were helped by a 26 percent jump in sales of inkjet printers and ink, and by a technology licensing deal with an undisclosed digital camera business which added about $250 million to gross profit in the quarter.
- The special consumer services group was the second-best performer, gaining 9 percent. The stock of the group’s single member, H&R Block, Inc., had sold off sharply during the prior two weeks on concerns over possible mortgage repurchase obligations and limited availability of funding for tax refund anticipation loans to its customers. Investor sentiment on the stock appeared to improve this week.
- The industrial real estate investment trust (REIT) group outperformed, rising 8 percent, led by the group’s single member, ProLogis. The large owner/developer of industrial warehouses expects to receive approximately $2.3 billion from its recently announced equity issuance and asset sales. These cash inflows, plus the company’s intention to reduce some of its debt, appeared to allay concerns over a possible debt-rating downgrade.
Weaknesses
- The tires & rubber group was the worst-performer, losing 13 percent, led by its single member, Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. The firm’s third quarter adjusted earnings exceeded the consensus estimate, but investors may have been disappointed by guidance for increased raw material costs in the fourth quarter.
- The personal products group underperformed, down 5 percent. Avon Products, Inc. reported third quarter revenue and earnings below the consensus estimates.
- The office real estate investment trust (REIT) group lost 5 percent, led by its single member, Boston Properties, Inc. The owner of office properties reported quarterly earnings above the consensus estimate, but a brokerage firm downgraded the stock’s rating to “market perform,” saying that Boston Properties’ strengths are already baked into its share price.
Opportunities
- There may be an opportunity for gain in merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions in 2010. Corporate liquidity is high, thereby providing the means to pursue acquisitions.
Threats
- Should investors’ expectations for an improving economy not come to fruition on a reasonable time frame, it could be a threat to stock prices.
- As governments around the world begin to wind down the monetary and fiscal stimulus programs put in place during the economic crisis, it will likely present a headwind for stocks.
Tags: Allegheny Technologies, Allegheny Technologies Inc, Analyst Consensus, Camera Business, Consumer Services Group, Eastman Kodak, Eastman Kodak Co, Estate Investment Trust, Fmc Corp, Industrial Warehouses, International Paper Co, Investor Sentiment, Loss Estimate, Market Diary, Real Estate Investment, Real Estate Investment Trust, Real Estate Investment Trust Reit, Refund Anticipation Loans, Tax Refund Anticipation Loans, Titanium Metals Corp
Posted in Markets | Comments Off
The Economy and Bond Market Diary (November 1, 2010)
Saturday, October 30th, 2010
The Economy and Bond Market Diary (November 1, 2010)
Treasury bond yields were mixed this week as the yield curve steepened and focus remains on the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting next week. Economic data was mixed to in line and was not a big driver of the market overall. Consumer confidence continues to be stuck in a rut as both the Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index (below) and the University of Michigan Confidence Index remains subdued.

Strengths
- Third quarter GDP grew 2 percent, right in line with expectations. Concerns are that 2 percent growth is right around “stall” speed for the economy and likely indicates that the Federal Reserve will act next week.
- Weekly initial jobless claims hit a 3-month low—claims fell 21,000 last week and the four week average is trending lower.
- Housing news was generally positive this week as September new home sales rose 6.6 percent and September existing home sales rose 10 percent.
Weaknesses
- Consumer confidence has not returned and consumers’ view of job conditions are at the lowest levels since February.
- Durable goods, ex-transportation orders, fell 0.7 percent in a possible sign that inventory accumulation is slowing.
- China’s central bank warned that inflationary pressures must be monitored closely. This comes a week after the central bank raised interest rates for the first time in three years.
Opportunities
- Inflation is unlikely to be a problem for some time, giving central bankers and other policymakers around the world room for expansive policies.
Threats
- Inflation expectations as measured by TIPS spreads have risen sharply this month. Inflation expectations will be key data points to drive Fed policy changes going forward.
Tags: Bond Market, China, Consumer Confidence Index, Durable Goods, Existing Home Sales, Fed Policy Changes, Federal Open Market Committee, Housing News, Inflation Expectations, Inflationary Pressures, Initial Jobless Claims, Key Data, Market Diary, Open Market Committee, Quarter Gdp, S Central, Stall Speed, Transportation Orders, Treasury Bond Yields, University Of Michigan Confidence, Yield Curve
Posted in China, Markets | Comments Off
Gold Market Diary (November 1, 2010)
Saturday, October 30th, 2010
Gold Market Diary (November 1, 2010)
For the week, spot gold closed at $1,359.40 per ounce, up $30.95, or 2.33 percent for the week. Gold equities, as measured by the Philadelphia Gold & Silver Index, rose 3.80 percent. The U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar Index fell 0.36 percent for the week.
Strengths
- Meng Qingfa, a researcher with the China Chamber of International Commerce, was quoted by the International Business Daily as saying that China should eventually boost its gold reserves to a level equal to that held by the United States. "Doubtlessly, if the yuan is set to become an international currency like the dollar or the euro, China has to get a huge gold reserve to support it, and a reserve of 1,054 tonnes is far from being enough," Meng said. U.S. reserves stood at 8,133 tonnes as of the end of June, significantly higher than China's current level of 1,054 tonnes.
- David Levenstein, a respected commodity analyst, recently noted his belief why gold has a strong future. Levenstein stated, “…no matter what your local politician tells you, the world is in a shambles. Most industrialized countries have slow GDP growth, high unemployment, huge sovereign debt as well as major budget deficits and interest rates at practically zero. Furthermore, around the world we are seeing rising commodity prices and major currency fluctuations. All this is going to lead to further currency debasement, and possibly both collective and unilateral government intervention in the forex market.”
- Commerzbank said Indian jewelry demand is currently accustomed to higher gold price levels. Commerzbank’s research indicated that India could very likely reach last year’s level of gold imports
Weaknesses
- With respect to the recent decline in the price of gold, Dennis Gartman, editor of the Gartman Letter, noted that “the inevitable correction has taken and may still be taking place in gold and we welcome that correction. It was and is much needed and the process of correcting has taken gold from being materially…perhaps even egregiously…overextended back toward long-term technical health.”
- As an investigation of the silver market by the top U.S. commodity regulator entered a third year, a member of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) said that there have been “repeated attempts” to influence prices. A five-member commission began investigating allegations of price manipulation in the silver futures market in September 2008.
- The CFTC said in a 2008 report that it had received “numerous letters, e-mails and phone calls” during the last 2 years alleging silver prices were being manipulated . The day after the release, JP Morgan Chase Bank and HSBC Holdings were hit with lawsuits accusing them of conspiring to drive down silver prices.
Opportunities
- Investor, mathematician and former fund manager Michael Berry, is bullish on gold, which he expects will double to around $3,000 per ounce within the next five years.
- Paul Horsnell, managing director of Barclays Capital, predicted that gold will first correct to $1,310 – $1,325 in early 2011, before rising steadily toward $1,450 by the middle of the year, based on support from central banks in Asia which are looking to diversify more of their reserves into gold. Horsnell predicts that gold will subsequently climb to his $1,850 target by the end of the following year, based on strong demand from emerging markets and factors limiting the supply of gold.
- John Embry, chief investment strategist of Sprott Asset Management, recently noted that the world remains in a financial bind, the likes of which it has probably never seen, and those people calling for corrections or bubbles in the gold market are flat out wrong. Embry added, “…everything I look at suggests much higher prices over the next 12 months.”
Threats
- In a recently released research report, based on two studies of South Africa’s energy future, RBC Capital Markets analyst Leon Esterhuizen highlighted “the very real possibility of the country running short of power for the most part of the next five years.” This could threaten platinum production in the region.
- A Bloomberg survey of traders, investors and analysts showed that the majority expect gold to decline next week, following this week’s negative reversal. Ten of 19 respondents were bearish on the yellow metal, while seven were bullish and two were neutral. The survey has been running for six years, and has correctly predicted the following week’s movement in 193 of 333 weeks, or 58 percent of the time.
- The aggregate S&P pension deficit was $264 billion at the end of 2009, and currently is around $380 billion, according to Bank of America Merrill Lynch. This would be the largest current deficit for all indexes. In another transfer of wealth, General Motors announced a $6 billion injection into its pension and health care plans versus a repayment to taxpayers.
Tags: China, China Chamber Of International Commerce, Commodity Prices, Currency Fluctuations, Dennis Gartman, Emerging Markets, Gartman Letter, GDP Growth, Gold Equities, Gold Imports, Gold Market, Gold Price, Gold Reserve, Gold Reserves, India, Indian Jewelry, International Currency, Levenstein, Market Diary, Philadelphia Gold, Price Of Gold, Rbc, Silver, Silver Index, Spot Gold
Posted in China, Gold, India, Markets, Silver | 1 Comment »
Energy and Natural Resources Diary (November 1, 2010)
Saturday, October 30th, 2010
Energy and Natural Resources Market Diary (November 1, 2010)

Strengths
- China’s imports of copper concentrate climbed to a record in September as smelters ramped up production in response to rising treatment charges. Inbound shipments jumped to 683,523 metric tons last month, up 22 percent year-over-year, the customs office said.
- World refined copper was in a deficit of 356 thousand metric tons year-to-date through July, compared with a deficit of 164 thousand metric tons in the same period in 2009, according to the International Copper Study Group.
- September imports of coking coal into China hit their highest levels since January of this year. China imported 4.17 million metric tons, up 7.5 percent sequentially according to Customs data.
Weaknesses
- Vietnam’s coal exports in 2011 are projected to drop 5.6 percent from this year to 17 million metric tons, a state-run newspaper said on Tuesday, as the country seeks to save more for domestic consumption. Coal exports would drop gradually to between 3 million and 4 million tonnes by 2015, the Rural Today newspaper said, citing an Industry and Trade Ministry report.
- China’s daily crude steel output fell further to 1.56 million metric tons in the second ten days of October, down 3.9 percent from early October, according to the China Iron & Steel Association.
Opportunities
- Russia, the world's top oil producer, will need over 8.6 trillion rubles ($280 billion) to keep pumping oil at current record levels until 2020, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin said on Thursday. “This is not an easy task,” Putin told a meeting of oil industry top managers and government officials. Putin was chairing a government meeting on a new 10-year energy strategy, which seeks to stave off output declines and encourage investment as the heartland of the Russian oil industry, the Soviet-era fields of West Siberia, goes on the wane.
- India, Asia’s second-fastest-growing major economy, may face a shortage of 60 million metric tons a year of power-plant coal by the year ending March 2012, as domestic output falls short of demand, Enam Securities Ltd. said.
- India, the world’s third-largest iron-ore exporter, should ban shipments overseas to ensure that local steelmakers have adequate supplies of the raw material, according to Steel Minister Virbhadra Singh. The country will need increased quantities of iron ore to meet domestic demand from steel producers, so there was a need for a ban, Singh said at a seminar in New Delhi this week.
- South Africa opened public hearings on a $125 billion energy plan to shift from dependency on coal while avoiding major price increases and a repeat of paralyzing blackouts in 2008. The draft plan proposes nearly halving the share of coal in the country’s energy mix to 48 percent by 2030, down from about 90 percent, using nuclear power and renewable energy such as wind and solar to make up the difference.
Threats
- Halliburton Co. may face increased liability in the Gulf of Mexico oil spill after the staff of a U.S. presidential panel said the contractor knew cement it mixed for BP Plc’s well was unstable. The staff of the National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill said documents provided by Halliburton showed at least three tests of the mixture, in February and April, found the recipe wasn’t stable. BP received data in March from at least one of the tests, the commission staff said in a letter this week.
Tags: Association Opportunities, China, Coal Exports, Commodities, Crude Steel, Customs Office, Domestic Consumption, energy, Inbound Shipments, India, India Asia, International Copper Study, International Copper Study Group, Market Diary, Million Metric Tons, Ministry Report, Natural Resources, oil, Output Declines, Refined Copper, Russia, Russian Oil Industry, Steel Association, Steel Output, Treatment Charges, Vladimir Putin, West Siberia
Posted in China, Energy & Natural Resources, India, Markets, Oil and Gas | Comments Off
Emerging Markets Diary (November 1, 2010)
Saturday, October 30th, 2010
Emerging Markets Diary (November 1, 2010)
Strengths
- Singapore’s unemployment rate fell to a better-than-expected 2.1 percent in the third quarter, the lowest in two and a half years, from 2.2 percent in the second quarter, as its services industry continued to expand thanks to the city-state’s two casino resorts launched earlier this year.
- Thailand’s central bank raised its 2010 GDP forecast for a third time this year from 7.3 percent to 8 percent year-over-year, from July’s estimate of 6.5 percent to 7.5 percent, encouraged by surging exports despite an appreciating local currency. Moody’s also raised Thailand’s credit rating outlook to stable from negative this week.
- Barring last minute surprises, the indications are that Dilma Rouseff will emerge victorious in the second round of presidential elections in Brazil on October 31. The markets will await with great interest the news about the composition of the next government for cues about the policies to be pursued in the post-Lula era. The broad consensus is that the next government is not likely to drastically change market-friendly policies that would jeopardize the favorable status that Brazil has achieved over the last eight years.
- Credit growth in Brazil in September reached 1.8 percent month-over-month, led by mortgage lending.
- Robust revenue growth in Turkey (19.0 percent year-to-date) should be sufficient to narrow the deficit by more than 2 percent this year to 3.2 percent of GDP. Performance is similar in Russia, where the budget deficit should narrow by almost 3 percent this year to 5.7 percent of GDP, though rapid increases in expenditure over recent years leaves the underlying budget situation very vulnerable to a downturn in oil prices.

Weaknesses
- South Korea’s GDP growth slowed to a worse-than-expected 0.7 percent sequentially in the third quarter from 1.4 percent in the second quarter, as a 7.2 percent local currency appreciation during the quarter weighed on exports, in addition to U.S. unemployment and European austerity.
- Although America Movil’s third quarter results were slightly higher than expected at the Revenue/EBITDA level, the reported EPS of $0.90 came around 20 percent lower than anticipated, leading to pressure on share prices.
- In Poland the central government deficit for the eight months ending in August more than doubled, while Prime Minister Donald Tusk now admits that this year’s deficit will be in the region of 7 percent to 8 percent of GDP, largely unchanged from last year. Strong foreign demand for bonds has supported the fixed income market to date, but such fiscal policy slippage risks EU wrath as well as a sharp decline in investor confidence at some stage.

Opportunities
- China has extended its total length of high speed rail to 7,431 kilometers (4,617 miles) with this week’s launching of the Shanghai-Hangzhou line, which cuts the travel time to only 45 minutes for a distance of 202 kilometers (126 miles). The length of high speed rail is planned to reach 13,000 kilometers (8,078 miles) by 2012. By dramatically increasing the speed of travel, China’s high speed rail may benefit sectors such as retail, restaurants and tourism because of the “one-city effect,” and in the long run, may have profound implications on labor mobility within the country.

- After a period of mourning following the death of Argentina’s former President, Nestor Kirchner, we expect a period of political instability in the short term, but a more market-friendly policy in the longer term, particularly after the election scheduled for October 2011. It remains to be seen if Christina Kirchner will run for president next year, a scenario that market participants might fear. However, we believe that a more conciliatory candidate, Carlos Reutemann (former governor of Santa Fe), might emerge and provide more stability for the country.
- After a period of mourning following the death of Argentina’s former President, Nestor Kirchner, we expect a period of political instability in the short term, but a more market-friendly policy in the longer term, particularly after the election scheduled for October 2011. It remains to be seen if Christina Kirchner will run for president next year, a scenario that market participants might fear. However, we believe that a more conciliatory candidate, Carlos Reutemann (former governor of Santa Fe), might emerge and provide more stability for the country.
- LAN, Chile’s airline, will purchase a controlling stake in Aires, the second largest airline of Colombia, where it has a 22 percent market share. We expect more competition in Colombia which should be advantageous for airline travelers.
- The acquisition streak by emerging market companies in the developed markets continues – Grupo Bimbo of Mexico is considering a purchase of Sara Lee’s baking assets in the U.S. for $1.3 billion.
- Emerging markets have historically exhibited very strong fourth quarter seasonality, according to Credit Suisse research. Since 1988 the fourth quarter has, on average, delivered a price return for the overall MSCI Emerging Markets Index of 6.0 percent, versus 4.7 percent for the first quarter, 3.7 percent for the second quarter and just 0.2 percent for the third quarter. Even during the 2008–2009 global financial crisis, the index returns were negative for all the months from June 2008 through February 2009, with the sole exception of December 2008 which posted a positive return of 7.6 percent. Strong fourth quarter seasonality is exhibited particularly by Turkey, Hungary and Russia.

Threats
- Rising prices for industrial metals and reaccelerating local currency appreciation in recent months may squeeze profit margins for export-oriented Chinese manufacturers going forward.
- The Czech Republic opposition Social Democrats won 12 seats in Senate elections, securing a majority in the chamber that may threaten the coalition government’s steps to cut the budget deficit, according to Bloomberg. The government had pledged to cut the budget deficit to the EU limit of 3 percent of economic output by 2013 from 5.8 percent last year.
Tags: Brazil, Budget Deficit, Budget Situation, Casino Resorts, China, Cues, Downturn, Elections In Brazil, Emerging Markets, Gdp Forecast, GDP Growth, Minute Surprises, Mortgage Lending, November 1, oil, Oil Prices, Presidential Elections, Rapid Increases, Russia, S Central, South Korea, Two And A Half Years, Unemployment Rate, Year To Date
Posted in Brazil, China, Energy & Natural Resources, Markets, Oil and Gas, Outlook | Comments Off
The Key to Better Sleep, Halloween Facts, and other Weekend Reads
Friday, October 29th, 2010
Here are this weekend's reading diversions for your personal enlightenment. Have a great Happy Halloween weekend!
Halloween Facts to share with the children
- Since 1995, trick or treating in the town of Sandusky, Ohio, has been against the law for anyone older then 14.
- It is very rare for a full moon to occur at the same time as Halloween. It has only occurred in — 1925, 1944, 1955, and 1974. The next time it is said to occur is 31 October, 2020.
- The word Halloween appeared in the Dictionary in the 1700s.
- According to ancient superstitions, if you stare into a mirror at midnight on Halloween, you'll see your future spouse.
- The pumpkin is one of the best sources of Vitamin A.
- Orange and black are Halloween colors because orange is associated with the Fall harvest and black is associated with darkness and death.
- Jack o’ Lanterns originated in Ireland where people placed candles in hollowed-out turnips to keep away spirits and ghosts on the Samhain holiday.
- Pumpkins also come in white, blue and green. Great for unique monster carvings!
- Halloween was brought to North America by immigrants from Europe who would celebrate the harvest around a bonfire, share ghost stories, sing, dance and tell fortunes.
- Tootsie Rolls were the first wrapped penny candy in America.
- The ancient Celts thought that spirits and ghosts roamed the countryside on Halloween night. They began wearing masks and costumes to avoid being recognized as human.
- Halloween candy sales average about 2 billion dollars annually in the United States.
- Chocolate candy bars top the list as the most popular candy for trick-or-treaters with Snickers #1.
- Halloween is the 2nd most commercially successful holiday, with Christmas being the first.
- Bobbing for apples is thought to have originated from the roman harvest festival that honors Pamona, the goddess of fruit trees.
- Black cats were once believed to be witch's familiars who protected their powers.
5 Ways To Keep Your Brain Active As You Age
I had a senior moment the other day. I was talking to my daughter about my elementary school, and I started listing my teachers one by one. But when I got to fifth grade, I drew a complete blank.
***
Prempro Hormone Therapy Amplifies Breast Cancer Risks, Study Finds
Women who took hormones and developed breast cancer were more likely to have cancerous lymph nodes, a sign of more advanced disease, and were more likely to die from the disease than were breast cancer patients who had never taken hormones.
***
Joanna Dolgoff, M.D.: Could an Earlier Bedtime Mean a Healthier Weight for Your Kids?
Babies and children under the age of five getting less than 10 hours of sleep at night are more likely to be overweight or obese five years later. Insufficient sleep at night may be a lasting risk factor for obesity later in life (napping cannot replace the benefits of nighttime sleep).
***
Dr. Michael J. Breus: Exercise: The Key to Better Sleep
If you're an insomniac, listen up: a new study from Northwestern Medicine that will be published in the journal Sleep Medicine soon showed serious promise to the dramatic effects of exercise on people diagnosed with insomnia.
***
Why Can’t Middle-Aged Women Have Long Hair? - NYTimes.com
MY mother hates it. My sister worries about it. My agent thinks I’m hiding behind it. A concerned friend suggests that it undermines my professional credibility. But in the middle of my life, I’m happy with it. Which is saying a lot about anything happening to my 55-year-old body.
***
Dr. Jim Taylor: Children and Responsibility: Teaching Kids the Importance of Following Through
Yet, as children are going to learn sooner or later, the real world of adulthood just doesn't work that way for us regular folk. To prepare your children for that real world, one of the great lessons they need to learn is that sometimes they just have to suck it up!
***
Health Canada weighs in on table salt - Parentcentral.ca
There’s good news and bad news when it comes to salt. Eat too much and you run the risk of heart disease. But because table salt is fortified with iodine, it helps ward off thyroid problems in adults and development delays in children.
***
Brian Gresko: In Defense of Childhood: Let Kids Be Kids!
Childhood is under attack by the very people who should be protecting it: parents.
***
Tags: Ancient Celts, Black Cats, Bobbing For Apples, Breast Cancer, Breast Cancer Patients, Breast Cancer Risks, Canadian Market, Cancerous Lymph Nodes, Candy Sales, Chocolate Candy, Dolgoff, Dr Jim, Dramatic Effects, Effects Of Exercise, First Wrapped Penny Candy, First Wrapped Penny Candy In America, Ghost Stories, Halloween Candy, Halloween Facts, Halloween Night, Halloween Weekend, Happy Halloween, Jim Taylor, Lesso, Middle Aged Women, Personal Enlightenment, Prempro, Professional Credibility, Risk Factor, Roman Harvest Festival, Sandusky Ohio, Senior Moment, Sleep At Night, Sleep Medicine, Spirits And Ghosts, Tootsie Rolls, Wearing Masks, Word Halloween
Posted in Canadian Market, Markets | Comments Off
Are Sovereign Wealth Funds The New Endowment Model?
Thursday, October 28th, 2010
Greg Bright of top1000funds.com reports, New endowment model: follow the SWFs:
Some sort of shape is starting to take place, post-global crisis, as to how the biggest, longest-term investors are spending their money. If the endowment model was the one to follow for the past 20 years, the sovereign wealth fund model may be the one to follow for the next.
Endowment-envy swept the world in the early part of this decade, which was probably a decade too late to reap the benefits from following the very clever investment strategies of the likes of Yale and Harvard. By the time of the global financial crisis, the envy had faded.But investors should think about why the endowment model of investing worked so well for as long as it did. If we can isolate the good things and then transport them to the post-crisis world, a new and better model may emerge. And, as always with investing, if the strategy is right, those in first will be rewarded.
What the big endowments did was invest directly, with their own teams of specialists and professionals, in areas where they had particular expertise, such as private equity and real estate. They then laid off the other parts of their portfolio in much the same way as big pension funds do anywhere, with a mix of growth and defensive allocations.
The problem was that in the crisis, correlations all went to one, and liquidity became a big issue. Endowments usually have to pay some income each year to their associated institution (such as a university), the same as a pension fund does with its retirees. But endowments don’t have a sponsor to top up the pot after one or two negative years. They have to rise and fall on their own merits.
Sovereign wealth funds are also a mixed bag of investors. Some of them have target dates for delivering on returns, some have target returns over various periods. Some are just set up to “make money” for the country by investing resources or foreign exchange reserve build-ups. Some are very transparent, others remain opaque.
What they have in common, though, is a single shareholder – a government – with a legislated genuine long-term aim for the fund’s investments.
Their investments, over the past 10-or-so years when the SWFs around the world have started to attract headlines, have also been a mixed bag. But a common element is the desire to take significantly large stakes in companies or other assets which reflect a long-term theme.
SWFs have, for instance, waded into hostile takeover battles for resource companies. They have invested directly in big infrastructure projects. And they have backed IPOs of established businesses which are targeting future growth areas.
This thematic focus has exacerbated political concerns about some SWFs being too nationalistic. Those from resource-importing countries taking big positions in resource exporters can be perceived as politically inspired. Or not.
But all investors can identify themes and direct their asset allocation accordingly. SWFs have the added advantages of fire-power to get a seat at any table and the inhouse resources to analyse and negotiate their positions.
A classic example of a thematic direct investment by a SWF from a resource-importing country, China, was written up last week in a client newsletter by HSBC, the global bank and fund manager.
In its case study, HSBC focused on a food stock which encompasses the two themes of globalisation and increasing demand for higher-protein food. The stock is Noble Group, based in Hong Kong and listed in Singapore. Last year, the China Investment Corporation, China’s $300 billion SWF, bought 15 per cent of Noble for $850 million.
Noble has operations in a lot of countries, vertically integrating its business and clipping the ticket at various points. It started life as a commodities trader but has grown into a supply chain manager of agricultural and energy products. One of its products is soya beans.
Soya beans, which have East Asian roots through history, are grown now mainly in South America and used for a range of products from animal feed and edible oils to soaps and biodiesel fuel.
Noble sells fertilisers to the South American soya bean farmers, buys the grain from them, stores it in Brazil and Argentina, crushes it, ships via its Noble Chartering subsidiary around the world – including China, which takes 37 per cent of the output – and sells to wholesalers.
Ricardo Leiman, Noble’s Brazilian-born chief executive, was quoted in the HSBC newsletter as saying that Noble and CIC will continue to look together for investment opportunities.
Tags: Allocations, Brazil, BRIC, BRICs, Canadian Market, China, Commodities, Correlations, Emerging Markets, Endowment, Endowments, Envy, Exchange Reserve, Foreign Exchange, Global Crisis, Global Financial Crisis, India, Investing Resources, Investment Strategies, liquidity, oil, Pension Fund, Pension Funds, Private Equity, Russia, SWFs, Target Dates, Target Returns, Term Investors, Ups
Posted in Brazil, Canadian Market, China, Emerging Markets, Energy & Natural Resources, India, Infrastructure, Markets, Oil and Gas | Comments Off
Jeremy Grantham: Investment Outlook (Fall 2010)
Thursday, October 28th, 2010
Jeremy Grantham, renowned chief of Boston's $104-billion GMO, shares his investment outlook in his latest quarterly, aptly titled, "Night of the Living Fed."
Among other things, Grantham says he likes being overweight high quality stocks and underweight low quality stocks. He feels investors should be moderately overweight emerging market equities, while moderately underweight the rest of the world. And, as for bonds, his thoughts are that while stocks in general are overpriced currently, bonds are even more so. Either way, Grantham's letter always makes for enlightening reading.
In summary (Grantham elaborates on each of the summarized points in the letter):
1) Long-term data suggests that higher debt levels are not correlated with higher GDP growth rates.
2) Therefore, lowering rates to encourage more debt is useless at the second derivative level.
3) Lower rates, however, certainly do encourage speculation in markets and produce higher-priced and therefore less rewarding investments, which tilt markets toward the speculative end. Sustained higher prices mislead consumers and budgets alike.
4) Our new Presidential Cycle data also shows no measurable economic benefits in Year 3, yet point to a striking market and speculative stock effect. This effect goes back to FDR, and is felt all around the world.
5) It seems certain that the Fed is aware that low rates and moral hazard encourage higher asset prices and increased speculation, and that higher asset prices have a benefi cial short-term impact on the economy, mainly through the wealth effect. It is also probable that the Fed knows that the other direct effects of monetary policy on the economy are negligible.
6) It seems certain that the Fed uses this type of stimulus to help the recovery from even mild recessions, which might be healthier in the long-term for the economy to accept.
7) The Fed, both now and under Greenspan, expressed no concern with the later stages of investment bubbles. This sets up a much-increased probability of bubbles forming and breaking, always dangerous events. Even as much of the rest of the world expresses concern with asset bubbles, Bernanke expresses none. (Yellen to the rescue?)
8) The economic stimulus of higher asset prices, mild in the case of stocks and intense in the case of houses, is in any case all given back with interest as bubbles break and even overcorrect, causing intense financial and economic pain.
9) Persistently over-stimulated asset prices seduce states, municipalities, endowments, and pension funds into assuming unrealistic return assumptions, which can and have caused fi nancial crises as asset prices revert back to replacement cost or below.
10) Artifi cially high asset prices also encourage misallocation of resources, as epitomized in the dotcom and fi ber optic cable booms of 1999, and the overbuilding of houses from 2005 through 2007.
11) Housing is much more dangerous to mess with than stocks, as houses are more broadly owned, more easily borrowed against, and seen as a more stable asset. Consequently, the wealth effect is greater.
12) More importantly, house prices, unlike equities, have a direct effect on the economy by stimulating overbuilding. By 2007, overbuilding employed about 1 million additional, mostly lightly skilled, people, not counting the associated stimulus from housingrelated purchases.
13) This increment of employment probably masked a structural increase in unemployment between 2002 and 2007, which was likely caused by global trade developments. With the housing bust, construction fell below normal and revealed this large increment in structural unemployment. Since these particular jobs may not come back, even in 10 years, this problem may call for retraining or special incentives.
14) Housing busts also help to partly freeze the movement of labor; people are reluctant to move if they have negative house equity. The lesson here is: Do not mess with housing!
15) Lower rates always transfer wealth from retirees (debt owners) to corporations (debt for expansion, theoretically) and the fi nancial industry. This time, there are more retirees and the pain is greater, and corporations are notably avoiding capital spending and, therefore, the benefi ts are reduced. It is likely that there is no net benefi t to artificially low rates.
16) Quantitative easing is likely to turn out to be an even more desperate maneuver than the typical low rate policy. Importantly, by increasing infl ation fears, this easing has sent the dollar down and commodity prices up.
17) Weakening the dollar and being seen as certain to do that increases the chances of currency friction, which could spiral out of control.
18) In almost every respect, adhering to a policy of low rates, employing quantitative easing, deliberately stimulating asset prices, ignoring the consequences of bubbles breaking, and displaying a complete refusal to learn from experience has left Fed policy as a large net negative to the production of a healthy, stable economy with strong employment.
Read the complete letter here in the slide deck, or download a copy (below slide deck)
You can download a .pdf copy here.
Hat Tip: MarketFolly.com
Tags: Asset Prices, Benefi, Debt Levels, Economic Benefits, Emerging Market, ETF, Fdr, Gdp Growth Rates, Greenspan, Investment Outlook, Jeremy Grantham, Letter 1, Low Quality, Moral Hazard, Quality Stocks, Recessions, Rewarding Investments, Speculative Stock, Stimulus, Term Impact, Wealth Effect
Posted in ETFs, Markets, Outlook | Comments Off
What Percentage of U.S. Equity Trades Are High Frequency Trades?
Thursday, October 28th, 2010
Several financial analysts have said that some 70% of American stock trades are high frequency trading:
- The former head of Nasdaq said that high frequency traders account for 73% of the volume on the stock market
- Joseph Saluzzi — partner and co-head of equity trading for Themis TradingThemis– puts the figure at 70%
- As does market analyst Peter Cohan
- And Raymond James analyst Patrick O’Shaughnessy
But the exact figure is difficult to ascertain.
One of the leading companies trying to estimate the percentage of HFT trades is the TABB Group. TABB's research director, Adam Sussman, wrote in October 2009:
Most HFT prop shops choose to keep their identities and intentions secretive, operating under the radar in the hope of improving their chance to profit.
***
The only art more forgivable than economic forecasting is estimating the market size of an industry that will never reveal its true number.
As of last October, Sussman estimated HFT to account for 61% of trades:
TABB Group estimates that high-frequency trading accounts for 61 percent of U.S. equity share volume (remember to double-count average daily shares!) and generates $8 billion per year in trading profits.
The methodology begins with an analysis of institutional equity trading volume that we have been collecting since 2006 from 115 U.S.-based equity head traders, including equity assets under management, average daily volume and the percentage of shares executed in blocks. We extrapolate that data to the broader institutional landscape. Retail trade numbers and data from the government are used to determine retail flow. Data from NYSE and Nasdaq and historical market making volumes enhances our picture of current electronic market-making volumes. Last but not least, we discussed our methodology and trading profit calculations (.0024/share) with several HFT hedge funds, independent high-frequency traders and registered market makers.
Sussman provided the following chart showing that its not just stocks, but that futures, options, bonds and currency are also traded using HFT:
However, earlier in the year, TABB released a 32-page report with 22 exhibits entitled "US Equity High-Frequency Trading: Strategies, Sizing and Market Structure", which placed the figure at 70% (revising the figure down from 73%):
Based on updated volume and trading data shared in the report, TABB Group revises its estimate of US equity trading volume to 70% from 73% as previously announced in July 2009 in a TABB commentary written by Iati, "The Real Story behind Trading Software Espionage," covered by financial and business media around the world.
"Throughout the report you'll find results of an August 2009 poll of 62 market participants on various components of current market structure," adds Sussman, "including flash trading, redefining front running, the tradeoff between order exposure and price improvement and the need for an SEC inquiry into market structure and the ability to achieve good execution.
So is it 70% or 61%?
As Cristina McEachern Gibbs notes, its both:
Recent TABB Group estimates indicate that 70 percent of U.S. equity trading volume, or 61 percent of share volume, is a result of high-frequency trading.
But how does TABB Group arrive at these numbers? Iati explains that there is a large amount of information available in the public domain, including information on assets under management (AUM) at hedge funds and retail order flow. The Westborough, Mass.-based advisory firm combines this publicly available information with proprietary data culled from its institutional research studies, such as average daily volume (ADV). Those numbers are then applied to the broader universe of trading stats. "We have our own sample as a proxy and use our sample of AUM and ADV to help model the broader marketplace," Iati says.
But a September 13 article from CNBC shows that that figure has declined since last year:
Total daily volume in all stocks listed at the New York Stock Exchange went from about 2 billion shares a day five years ago, to an average of about 5 billion shares a day today. High-frequency trading now accounts for about 56 percent of trading volume, according to Tabb Group, but Tabb notes that this figure includes market makers. Five years ago, it was practically nothing.
Who's trading? Here's the latest breakdown of daily volume (source: Tabb Group):
- High-Frequency Trading: 56 percent (includes proprietary trading shops, market makers, and high-frequency trading hedge funds)
- Institutional: 17 percent (mutual funds, pensions, asset managers)
- Hedge Funds: 15 percent
- Retail: 11 percent
- Other: 1 percent (non-proprietary banking)
Gibbs notes that not everyone agrees with TABB's numbers:
Though sophisticated, TABB Group's methodology is not an exact science, and the industry's high-frequency-trading numbers are still up for debate. Woodbine's Samelson pegs high-frequency trading at about 40 percent of overall market volume today, with electronic trading accounting for up to 70 percent of total equity volume. According to Samelson, however, it is extremely difficult to put a dollar amount on this volume. Joseph Mecane, EVP and chief administrative officer for U.S. markets at NYSE Euronext, estimates that at least half of the liquidity in the market is generated by high-frequency trading or automated market making.
The bottom line is that unless the government forces reporting by traders, it will be difficult to shine a light into the high frequency trading world bright enough to determine what the exact numbers are.
Hat tip Tyler Durden.
Copyright © George Washington's Blog
Tags: American Stock, Economic Forecasting, Electronic Market, Equity Assets, Equity Share, Equity Trading, Exact Figure, Flow Data, Institutional Equity, Institutional Landscape, Market Analyst, Peter Cohan, Profit Calculations, Saluzzi, Share Volume, Stock Trades, Tabb Group, Trade Numbers, Trading Accounts, True Number
Posted in Markets | Comments Off
Not Just Stocks ... High Frequency Traders are Spinning Futures, Options, Bonds, Currency and Commodities Markets As Well
Thursday, October 28th, 2010
As I noted earlier today, high frequency traders trade not only stocks, but also futures, options, bonds and currency:
We know that high frequency trading is used to manipulate the stock market. The prevalence of high frequency trading in other markets means that it might be used to manipulate those markets — perhaps virtually all markets — as well.
Indeed, by manipulating futures prices, it is possible to manipulate the current price of the underlying asset.
As the New York Times reported in September 2009:
It could well be that Optiver’s cowboy trading tactics [manipulating the price of oil through high frequency trading] are unique to the company. But as concern grows over the effect that high-octane computerized trading is having on markets worldwide, Optiver’s conduct in the oil futures market raises questions as to whether the relentless competition of this business is forcing companies to engage in similar practices. “These are proprietary trading shops that are masquerading as market makers,” said Tim Quast of Modern IR, a consulting firm that advises corporations on market structure issues.The Securities and Exchange Commission has opened up an investigation into high-speed-trading practices, in particular the ability of some of the most powerful computers to jump to the head of the trading queue and — in a fraction of a millisecond — capture the evanescent trading spread before the rest of the market does.
Copyright © George Washington
Tags: C George, Commodities, Computerized Trading, Consulting Firm, Futures Commodities, Futures Market, Futures Options, Futures Prices, George Washington, High Frequency, Market Structure Issues, Millisecond, New York Times, oil, Oil Futures, Optiver, Powerful Computers, Price Of Oil, Proprietary Trading, Quast, Relentless Competition, Securities And Exchange Commission, Stocks Bonds
Posted in Energy & Natural Resources, Markets, Oil and Gas | Comments Off
Debt Bubbles and the Bull Market for Commodities
Thursday, October 28th, 2010
The “World’s Greatest Investment Event,” the 2010 New Orleans Investment Conference kicked off on Wednesday as gold and natural resources investors descended on the Crescent City for answers to today’s market questions.
The list of speakers for this year’s conference reads like a who’s who of the natural resources and commodity world—Dr. Marc Faber, Newt Gingrich, Dennis Gartman, Dick Armey, Peter Schiff and others.
We know everyone can’t make it down to the conference this year, so we’re going to be sharing some of the highlights with you over the next couple of days.
Rick Rule, chairman of Global Resource Investments, Ltd., was first to speak Thursday morning and he had a clear message for the audience: We’re in a bull market for commodities and natural resources. Rule said that the easy money, what he called “riskless” money, has been made, but the “big” money is still out there.
Rule cautioned that this bull market in natural resources comes with a hefty amount of volatility; however, he told the audience of several hundred to use the volatility to their advantage. Rule said “volatility means items are continually being sold at 30, 40 and 50 percent off.”
One big reason Rule cites for the bull market in commodities and resources are supply-side constraints. A severe bear market in the 1980s and 1990s kept many companies and governments from investing in exploration and today’s consumers are living off reserves discovered in the 1960s and 1970s. With per capita consumption growing in places like China, new discoveries will need to be large and fruitful to prevent supply shocks.
Next up on the stage was Brien Lundin, editor of the Gold Newsletter and host of the New Orleans Investment Conference. Lundin began his presentation on gold showing that the current rally—which he says began in August 2009—has taken longer and appreciated less than recent run-ups in 2006 and 2008.
Lundin says he has been expecting a correction in gold prices that has not come to fruition. This could likely come when the Federal Reserve institutes their second edition of quantitative easing because market expectations have just gotten too high.
Lundin is also positive on copper, saying that analysts have been trying to kill off copper for years but the Chinese have refused to play along. Lundin thinks we’ll see $4 a pound copper sooner rather than later.
Although Lundin thinks a pullback in gold prices is coming, he believes this is the time for investors to reload. His long-term bullish view on gold is based on unprecedented debt levels by the Fed and the oncoming devaluation of nearly every major currency in the world.
Bubble-spotter Peter Schiff led off the mid-day session with a discussion of bubbles and excessive government spending. Schiff says we’re currently experiencing one of the biggest bubbles in history; it’s not a bubble in equities, not in gold or commodities, but a bubble in government. The rest of his half hour speech laid out the case supporting this argument. Schiff says that the 2008 housing bubble was the overture to a much greater debt opera that is nowhere complete.
While Schiff spent his time at the podium explaining where a bubble is, newsletter mavens Pamela and Mary Ann Aden spent their time onstage explaining where there isn’t one—in gold. Mary Ann Aden began by laying out the history of gold’s trip from $200 in the 1990s to more than $1,300 today. One of the biggest drivers has been the explosion of government debt. Mary Ann said that if the government paid $1 million a day on its debt, it would take nearly 2,000 years to pay it off.
Mary Ann said that gold is far from a bubble because of the world’s reliance on paper currency and “there’s not one paper currency in the history of the world that has survived.” Mary Ann says that central banks have seen the writing on the wall and that’s why you’ve seen a pickup in central bank buying of gold this year. Mary Ann’s sister Pamela Aden proclaimed in her speech that gold is currently in a “once in a lifetime” megabull market.
We’ll have more updates from other speakers tomorrow.
![]()
Tags: Advantage Rule, Bear Market, Brien Lundin, China, Commodities, Crescent City, Dennis Gartman, Dick Armey, Dr Marc Faber, Easy Money, energy, Global Resource, Gold Newsletter, Investment Conference, Investments Ltd, List Of Speakers, Natural Resources, New Discoveries, Newt Gingrich, Peter Schiff, S Market, Side Constraints, Supply Shocks, Ups, Volatility
Posted in China, Energy & Natural Resources, Gold | Comments Off
Where is the Edge in Today's Market?
Wednesday, October 27th, 2010
by Elliot Turner, Wall Street Cheat Sheet
Before my article from yesterday travels too far, I want to take a moment and dig into what I believe to be the most important conclusion to draw from it. Here is the relevant clip:
Over the past ten years, trading was wildly successful relative to buy and hold investing. The pronouncement that this relationship will continue into the future seems to be coming from those who are now trying to train more than trade, or those who missed the boat and are attempting to play catchup.
The evidence proves computers now own the short-term, but humans still own the long-term. Getting back to my conversation with Justin Fox, over the past decade “price efficiency” ruled in creating a substantial opportunity for traders. In today’s market, earnings multiples are so compressed that “value efficiency” creates an equally great opportunity for buy and hold investors.
For the most part, I take pronouncements with regard to the market in relative terms, not absolutes. No one statement in and of itself should be interpreted as a black or white pronouncement where only A or B can and will be true. The past decade, which many have labeled the “end of buy and hold” saw plenty of investors succeed with buy and hold. Meanwhile, watching CNBC or reading a wide variety of financial and trading-centric bloggers would have one believe that neither the S&P nor Dow went up over the last 10 years therefore buy and hold unilaterally did not work. The truth is not so simple. While many struggled with buy and hold there were some who succeeded.
Tags: 10 Years, Absolutes, Bloggers, Buy And Hold, Catchup, Cheat Sheet, Cnbc, Day Trading, Decade, Dow, Earnings, Elliot Turner, Justin Fox, Price Efficiency, Pronouncement, Pronouncements, Relative Terms, S Market, Substantial Opportunity, Wall Street
Posted in Markets | Comments Off
QE Disappoints?
Wednesday, October 27th, 2010
Note and Chart by Econompic Data
Bloomberg details:
“The market is consumed with QE,” said John Spinello, chief technical strategist in New York at Jefferies Group Inc., one of 18 primary dealers that trade with the Fed. “There are indications that the marketplace is disappointed at the fact that it’s more than likely not going to be a huge initial undertaking and no one knows the amount.”
Is the daily performance the result of this lack of QE?
Or perhaps investors have realized a 10–20% run up in risk assets / real assets in a month (due to QEII) is a bit ridiculuous...
Copyright © Econompic Data
Tags: Investors, Jefferies Group, Jefferies Group Inc, Marketplace, Qe, Real Assets, risk, Spinello, Technical Strategist, Undertaking
Posted in Markets | Comments Off
Long Bond Breaks Support
Wednesday, October 27th, 2010
Note and Chart by Bespoke Investment Group
With QE2 on the way, there are a contingent of investors who believe that even with interest rates near record low levels, long-term US Treasuries are a can't lose proposition. The argument goes that if the economy is weak, Treasuries will rally, and if the economy stabilizes or picks up, purchases by the Fed will support prices. While the argument sounds good in theory, those buying Treasuries based on this logic have been losing. The chart below shows the performance of US long-term Treasuries over the last six months. Since their peak in August, they have declined over 5%, and just in the last two days they've broken below levels that had been acting as short-term support.

Copyright © Bespoke Investment Group
Tags: Bespoke Investment Group, Contingent, Copyright, Economy, interest rates, Investors, Logic, Qe2, Six Months, Treasuries
Posted in Markets | Comments Off
Early November Looms Large for Markets
Wednesday, October 27th, 2010
Key Dates Approaching
October 25 – October 29, 2010
Dr. Scott Brown, Chief Economist, Raymond James
The first week of November looms large for the markets. The November 2 mid-term elections are expected to result in a power shift on Capitol Hill – but how much will actually change? The Fed’s November 3 monetary policy decision has important implications for interest rates, the dollar, and the economy in general. The October Employment Report (due November 5) will help shape the near-term economic outlook and set expectations for future Fed policy moves.
For those of you who slept through civics class in high school, recall that all 435 seats in the House of Representatives are contested every two years. Senators serve six-year terms – so about of third of the 100 seats in the Senate are contested every two years (37 seats are being contested this year, due to the death of Robert Byrd and the resignations of Joe Biden and Hillary Clinton). As we head toward the wire, there are a number of close races. Recent polling suggests that the Republicans have a good chance of regaining a majority in the House and a small chance of taking control of the Senate.
Will the election results change anything in Washington? It will in the House, where a simple majority is needed to pass legislation. The Senate is more complicated. As it is now, the Democrats have a 59 seat in the Senate, one short of a supermajority. You need 60 votes in the Senate to avoid the threat of a filibuster – and thus, you need 60 votes just to be able to vote on a bill. In addition, one senator can put a hold on any or all legislation, meaning that the floor leader is informed that the senator does not want a particular bill to come to the floor for a vote (and implicitly threatens a filibuster of any motion to consider the measure). So, anyone believing that a Republican victory will lead to a dramatic change in the direction of legislation will be disappointed.
Yet, perceptions matter. The stock market is likely to view a Republican majority in the House as a check on the White House. During the Clinton years, gridlock was good. The Republicans didn’t get massive tax cuts and the Democrats didn’t get any major spending programs, and we ended up with a federal budget surplus (the Clinton era was also well served by PAYGO rules, which required any legislative changes to be budget neutral). However, in the current environment, stuff might actually need to get done to boost the economy. While there are bound to be disagreements about the best way to do this, nothing significant is likely to get done.
The Fed’s November 3 policy decision is not a done deal. There are differences of opinion, but most Fed officials, including Chairman Bernanke, have been leaning toward further monetary accommodation. The key element is expected to be an announcement to purchase a specified amount of long-term Treasuries over a certain period of time. This should be on a much smaller scale than in the first round of credit easing ($1.25 trillion in mortgage-backed securities and $300 billion in Treasuries purchased last year), allowing the Fed more flexibility (to do more if needed or to stop if growth picks up). Will quantitative easing be inflationary? Yes, hopefully – at least to some extent. Inflation is too low for the Fed’s comfort. It’s real (that is, inflation-adjusted) interest rates that matter. The drop in inflation expectations has lifted real rates, dampening the pace of economic growth. Raising inflation expectations would lower real rates, stimulating growth. Still, it’s not an easy decision. There are positives and negatives to just about any Fed policy decision. Many fear that the Fed will not be able to withdraw accommodation in time and fuel substantial higher inflation in the future. However, officials are confident that the Fed can drain bank reserves in a timely manner when appropriate. The Fed has spent much of this year testing the exits (reverse repos, term deposits for depository institutions).
The Federal Open Market Committee may announce efforts beyond asset purchases. It may commit to a longer period of low short-term interest rates. It could also announce an inflation target or a target rate for long-term Treasury yields.
After the shock and awe of the mid-term elections and the Fed policy decision, the financial markets will face the October Employment Report. The impact of the 2010 census is behind us. Since January 2009, federal government payrolls have risen a bit less than the rate of population growth (so much for the “massive” expansion of government). State and local government payrolls have fallen, reflecting budget strains (despite federal aid to the states), which has acted as moderate drag on overall economic growth. Private-sector job growth has been positive, but relatively subpar in recent months. Expect more of the same in the job report for October.
Copyright © Raymond James
Tags: Chief Economist, Dr Scott, Dramatic Change, Early November, Economic Outlook, Employment Report, Fed Policy, Floor Leader, Hillary Clinton, Joe Biden, Key Dates, Policy Decision, Policy Moves, Power Shift, Raymond James, Republican Victory, Resignations, Robert Byrd, Set Expectations, Supermajority
Posted in Markets, Outlook | Comments Off









